# Comparison results: settings-form

[Comparison overview, scores, protocol and limits](why-no-skill.md)

All nine settings-form builds from the 2026-10-15 cohort follow unchanged: three arms, three runs each. These checks grade the resulting apps, not operational safety, complete accessibility or physical-device VoiceOver behavior. Read the overview's protocol notes and limits before comparing scores.

## Every run and check

### settings-form, shadcn/ui, run 1: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | shadcn | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/shadcn/settings-form/1/score/screenshots.

### settings-form, shadcn/ui, run 2: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | shadcn | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/shadcn/settings-form/2/score/screenshots.

### settings-form, shadcn/ui, run 3: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | shadcn | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/shadcn/settings-form/3/score/screenshots.

### settings-form, shadcn/ui with its skill, run 1: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | shadcn-skill | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/shadcn-skill/settings-form/1/score/screenshots.

### settings-form, shadcn/ui with its skill, run 2: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | shadcn-skill | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/shadcn-skill/settings-form/2/score/screenshots.

### settings-form, shadcn/ui with its skill, run 3: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | shadcn-skill | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/shadcn-skill/settings-form/3/score/screenshots.

### settings-form, Ouro HX, run 1: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | ouro | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/ouro/settings-form/1/score/screenshots.

### settings-form, Ouro HX, run 2: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | ouro | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/ouro/settings-form/2/score/screenshots.

### settings-form, Ouro HX, run 3: 100/100

| Screen | Arm | Score | Typecheck | Lint | Axe | Behavior |
| --- | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| settings-form | ouro | 100 | 20/20 | 10/10 | 20/20 | 50/50 |

Every check passed.

Problems the app had before the agent ran, which cost nothing: 0 type errors, 0 lint errors.

| Behavior check | Acceptance items | Viewport | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| The six fields have visible labels, come in order, show the loaded settings, and Bio has its hint | 1 | desktop | pass |
| While saving, the button is disabled or marked busy and the form can't be sent again by click or Enter | 2 | desktop | pass |
| A server error shows under its field, marks it invalid, is read with it, and focus moves there | 3 | desktop | pass |
| With two errors, each shows on its field and focus moves to the first | 3 | desktop | pass |
| Correcting the field and saving again clears its error | 4 | desktop | pass |
| "Settings saved" appears in a live region after a successful save | 5 | desktop | pass |
| At 390px wide the page does not scroll sideways | 6 | phone | pass |

| Axe | Result |
| --- | --- |
| 390px light | pass |
| 390px dark | pass |
| 1280px light | pass |
| 1280px dark | pass |

Screenshots, as evidence only: 8 in scripts/agent-usability/runs/2026-10-15/ouro/settings-form/3/score/screenshots.